Create a common basis before comparing
Give every person the same project description: intended use, photographs, an informational sketch, features to retain, and open decisions. If a proposal uses a different location, finish, or access assumption, do not treat it as equivalent merely because its heading sounds similar.
Ask for assumptions to be identified. An assumption may depend on a visit, drawing, product document, supplier, or competent authority. Marking it as pending is not a defect; it prevents a conversation from becoming a commitment no one can review.
- The project objective and limits being compared.
- Version and date of every document.
- Included, excluded, and unconfirmed scope.
- Person or entity identified for each work item.
Read scope by work item and boundary
Do not compare only a total. Check whether each proposal names site preparation, access, equipment, surrounding surfaces, restoration, filings, coordination, and handover where relevant. An item without a description may be an exclusion, a pending condition, or simply an unanswered question.
Ask for a written route for changes: who proposes them, which document is updated, and which other decisions they may affect. When scope changes, a verbal statement should not replace a revised version.
| Topic | Question for every proposal | Useful record |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Which work and materials are named? | Inclusions and exclusions |
| Responsibility | Who coordinates this item? | Name or entity in the document |
| Assumption | What needs confirmation? | Source or pending review |
| Change | How is it approved and recorded? | Revised version |
Verify what a planning page cannot certify
Request legal or trade names exactly as they appear in documents, checkable contact details, and a route to verify credentials where relevant. References should be independently checkable; a logo, photograph, or review does not by itself establish capacity, coverage, or compliance.
Do not request or share unnecessary personal information. Keep documents, questions, and answers in a private folder, and consult the competent person or authority when a decision needs a professional determination.
Finish with a readable comparison
Make a table with one row per work item and one column per proposal. Mark “not stated” rather than inferring a favorable inclusion. Before hiring, check which version you are accepting and retain unanswered questions. A decision can remain pending until enough information exists.
Frequently asked questions
Is the shortest proposal necessarily less expensive?
No. It may describe less scope, use different assumptions, or leave work items unnamed. Ask for clarification before comparing it.
Does this guide validate a builder?
No. It helps organize review; credentials, conditions, and determinations must be checked with the competent source.
Español